magicalhippo
6 hours ago
Will be interesting to see how long this RAM insanity will last. If it doesn't calm down before Zen 6 releases, people like me on older platforms might just have to skip Zen 6 entirely and wait for the AM6 platform.
FootballMuse
5 hours ago
Reportedly, Zen 7 will also be on AM5.
https://overclock3d.net/news/cpu_mainboard/amd-extends-am5-l...
rafaelmn
4 hours ago
Can they double the memory lanes without switching socket ? If not I feel like PC is going to fall behind even further compared to Apple chips. Having ram on chip sucks for repairability but 500gb/s main ram bandwidth is insane.
They stumbled into the right direction with strix halo but I have a feeling they won't recognize the win/follow up.
zamadatix
2 hours ago
The "insane" RAM bandwidth makes sense with Apple M chips and Strix Halo because it's actually "crap" VRAM bandwidth for the GPU. What makes those nice is the quantity of memory the GPU has (even though its slow), not that the CPU has tons of RAM bandwidth.
When you go to the desktop it becomes harder to justify including beefed up memory controllers just for the CPU vs putting that towards beefing some other part of the CPU up that has more of an impact in cost or performance.
dogma1138
4 hours ago
Not easily, and you will need a new motherboard anyhow because each of the 2 slots you can have per lane are wired in tandem.
Numerlor
4 hours ago
The socket io locks in the amount of memory channels. Some pins could be repurposed but that's pretty much a new socket anyway.
They could in theory do on package dram as faster first level memory, but I doubt we'll see that anytime soon on desktop and it probably wouldn't fit under the heat spreader
nutjob2
an hour ago
> Can they double the memory lanes without switching socket?
Sure. Keep the DIMM sockets and add HBM to the CPU package.
Actually probably the best possible architecture. You can choose to have both or only one, backward compatible and future proof.
Yes, it adds another level to the memory hierarchy but that can be fine tuned.
tpurves
3 hours ago
So Zen 6/7 will have a core design and a CCD design. But like past gens, these will be packaged into different products with different sockets and packages (everything from monolithic APUs to sprawling multi-chiplet Server cpus).
So to say that Zen 6/7 supports AM5 on desktop, doesn't necessarily exclude that Zen 6/7 product family in general doesn't support other new/interesting sockets on desktop (or mobile) also. Maybe products for AM6 and AM5 from the same zen family.
Medusa Halo and the Zen7 based 'Grimlock Halo' version might be the interesting ones to watch (if you like efficient Apple-stlyle big APUs with all the memory bandwidth)
Pet_Ant
5 hours ago
Higher DRAM prices might mean that there is less demand from new system builders mean depressed prices so it might be more tempting to upgrade your existing AM5 CPU to Zen 6
Ritewut
5 hours ago
I would figure the opposite. There are plenty of people like me staying on AM4 because of the RAM price increases. I will probably skip AM5 entirely.
Pet_Ant
5 hours ago
But they are still gonna fab the Zen 6 chips. So for people already with AM5 motherboards populated with RAM but rocking a Zen 4 CPU this could be a good time to upgrade that CPU with your existing setup. You passing this generation just means less competition for those CPUs which should make them even cheaper.
Macha
5 hours ago
My understanding is they’re using the same process time for cpus and gpus so they may just be able to reallocate it for datacenter gpus. Sure they’re behind but some of the AI companies have already made deals with them as they just want compute, any compute. So I think the effect might be less than some hope for
0cf8612b2e1e
5 hours ago
I am a hypocrite, but there is really not that much need to upgrade CPUs anymore. Even a ten year old chip seems completely adequate for day to day use. I played with a N100 recently and those things are incredibly capable.
(Ignore my AM5 workstation with 192GB RAM in the corner)
bikelang
5 hours ago
I rocked my Haswell i5 until last year when I built a brand new machine around the 9800x3d. Along the way I upgraded it from 8gb of ram to 32gb, got a gen 1 pcie3 NVME, and went through successive hand-me-down GPUs starting from a GeForce 770 to the RTX 2070 it has now.
In fact my wife is still rocking that machine - although her gaming needs are much less equipment intense than mine. After a small refurb I gave it (new case, new air cooler, new PSU) - I expect it to last another 5 years for her.
ocdtrekkie
4 hours ago
I rode out an i7-4790K until this year... replaced solely because of Windows 10 support ending. But it's a solid chip.
My new one is a 9700X. Didn't feel the need to spring for higher power budget for a marginal gaming performance bump. But I suppose that also means it's much more practical for me to jump to a newer CPU later.
johnbellone
5 hours ago
I really wish I would've bought 192G when it was less than a few thousand dollars!
0cf8612b2e1e
4 hours ago
Heh. It was a luxury purchase at the start of the year when I was only worried about tariffs. Wanted to lock in a new build good for years. Every once in a while I have a machine learning project that needs over 100GB and so it is nice not to have to overthink things. Honestly, I’m kicking myself I did not go all the way with 256GB.
Sohcahtoa82
5 hours ago
Depends wildly on what you're doing.
I'm a gamer, often playing games that need a BEEFY CPU, like MS Flight Simulator. My upgrade from an i9-9900K to a Ryzen 9800X3D was noticeable.
imtringued
5 hours ago
You say that, but DDR6 will double the memory bandwidth over DDR5. This means modern systems will go beyond 200GB/s memory bandwidth just for the CPU alone.
kvemkon
4 hours ago
> DDR6 will double the memory bandwidth over DDR5
Considering PC desktops. DDR4 is 3200 MT/s max JEDEC. DDR5 is available on AMD since 3 years and is 5600. DDR6 specification is almost finished. It looks like DDR5 will double performance just right before new DDR6 DIMMs appear. Thus I'd expect DDR6 to double the bandwidth just as late when the new memory standard arrives.
yetihehe
32 minutes ago
> DDR5 is available on AMD since 3 years and is 5600
Strange, I bought 64GB DDR5 6400MHz last year and apparently my motherboard can handle up to 7200MHz (or more with overclocking).
kvemkon
20 minutes ago
Though clarified at the start about Desktop, but missed JEDEC applying, of course, generally for the whole post.
0cf8612b2e1e
5 hours ago
And? What real world impact will that have for people typing up an email and browsing the web?
glitchc
5 hours ago
It majes a huge difference for local AI models.
PunchyHamster
5 hours ago
and do what, buy now-hideously expensive DDR6?
parineum
5 hours ago
> less demand from new system builders mean depressed prices
Only if they overestimate demand and overproduce CPUs. Otherwise it will lead to higher prices because there's less economy of scale.
burnt_toast
4 hours ago
Hopefully it settles down soon. DDR4 prices are climbing now as well since more people are sticking with it.
I'd love to build a new desktop soon but I couldn't justify the cost and am instead building out a used desktop that's still on ddr4 / lga1151.
nottorp
3 hours ago
Holy ram prices man!
I just checked how much the 64 Gb ddr4 in my desktop would cost now... it starts at 2.5 times what i paid in 2022.
Sorry AMD, I would maybe like a new desktop but not now.
XCSme
4 hours ago
I hope they'll release a new AM4 CPU
Something like 5900x on 2nm or 4nm