simonw
a day ago
Anything where an LLM asks you a question without disclosing that it's an LLM is an abomination.
I get these on Twitter all the time, and they're starting to show up on Bluesky as well.
Most of my tweets have 20+ garbage spam replies now. I don't read them any more, which sucks because I used to get to talk to actual people there.
The ones that ask a question are particularly offensive because they risk you falling for them and wasting several minutes of your time thinking about and then responding to them... when no human being ever asked or cares about the answer.
SyneRyder
a day ago
Not that this will help, but I saw one guy on Twitter who was actively selling those engagement question replies as a service. I know Levelsio was working on a shared blocklist to try and stop them, and you'd think Elon could just block this MagnetX service directly on the X side.
KellyCriterion
a day ago
Are there any business numbers available on this very creative business? :-)
dovin
a day ago
In my experience Pangram has been, if not perfect, then at least good enough for my purposes, and I'm glad that at least the big labs seem incentivised to have text outputs to be clearly identified as written by AI.
Probably doesn't help with Twitter though because individual engagement-baiting messages will probably be too short, but... makes me wonder if we're going to move to something more like an answering-machine internet where we're using LLMs as intermediaries in any and all lower-trust environments (which seems like it would be anywhere strangers can congregate?) or if it's going to be more like proof-of-humanity or just proof-of-attention.
avinoth
14 hours ago
Oh, that is why I never get any replies on genuine questions on X anymore. I rarely engage on X, and when I do, it's mostly for something that was interesting or something I could learn from. I've never got any replies. TBF it is a fresh X account as I deleted my old one when it was being brigaded by trolls a few years back.
Now, it seems impossible to talk with anyone anymore on any platforms.
Ancapistani
20 hours ago
> Anything where an LLM asks you a question without disclosing that it's an LLM is an abomination.
Yep.
I’m in a job search right now, and am using a Hermes agent to manage it. I’ve had it go through my email archive and that of a couple of friends, and email every recruiter I can find. It’s been very successful - I have >40 initial interviews set up over the next two weeks.
The key reason I’ve had success, IMO, is that the very first line of the email identifies that it is an agent, its purpose, and goal. It closes with a description of the overall automated process I’ve built.
I did an informal survey of about a dozen randomly-selected respondents, and they all seemed to be of the opinion that if anything, it saved them time. They asked for the information they needed, got it within a couple of minutes, and my agent either scheduled a meeting or politely declined if the jobs they had didn’t meet my hard requirements.
AI can be extremely helpful, even in dealing with other humans en masse. Not disclosing it feels dishonest at best and fraudulent at worst.
robeym
15 hours ago
40 interviews over 2 weeks? What are you applying for? And where?
giancarlostoro
a day ago
What annoys me is people calling others LLMs or bots without proof. I've seen literal friends who I know aren't botting or using LLMs to post on social media being accused of it. It's just gotten out of control. Meanwhile captchas get more ridiculous, soon you'll need to hire a bot to get in.
simonw
12 hours ago
My trick for identifying bot accounts is to go and look at their other messages. If they have dozens of tweets equally spread across time (they don't work or sleep) that are replies to popular users, of approximately the same length, ending in a question mark, and that didn't get any replies... they're a bot.
dimava
17 hours ago
If I want to call someone a bot (and the post is >50 words) I don't even bother saying anything, I just call @Pangram (and block if its a bot to demote)
dvh
a day ago
You're absolutely right. It's not just accusations, it's hostility. Like splash of sunlight on dark sky. Let's delve into the intricacies of ever increasing captcha difficulty...
giancarlostoro
a day ago
Lol, funny, but it does happen on HN too.
bradknowles
a day ago
I thought that x/itter was a write-only medium? At least, that’s the way I treat it….
Loquebantur
a day ago
The point of answering questions in public spaces is the public, not the person (or LLM) posing one?
While faking human interaction possibly should be prohibited outright, one cannot ever be sure that is being adhered to? And humans can be disingenuous as well to begin with.
It's how you engage in a discussion and conduct yourself that matters, because other people are there witnessing it.
Now, when that LLM fakes human sentiment and you or others fall for it, that is a problem beyond the use of LLMs? The same would be true with sock puppets operated by real people, only the scale differs.
When you solve that problem, by putting high value on the factual and logical truth of statements for instance, you solve multiple problems at once.
BeetleB
a day ago
> Most of my tweets have 20+ garbage spam replies now. I don't read them any more, which sucks because I used to get to talk to actual people there.
Genuinely curious: Is it the same when you post on Mastodon?
(I've occasionally interacted with you there).