Ask HN: Can we do something about this impending AI dystopia

4 pointsposted 18 hours ago
by justforfunhere

Item id: 50256342

6 Comments

uncomplexity

an hour ago

who's "we" here? because i can't really relate.

you sound more concerned about your job security than getting the job done itself.

with AI our role just transcends to being captains of the ship, plotting marks in the map and steering the wheel as AI does the rowing of the oars.

i do understand how much enjoyable it is rowing the oars ourselves but it's time to take the wheel, cap.

AlbertoSalviaNo

17 hours ago

I don't know about you, but no agent was able to write the code I make to this day.

Agents have been useful at providing examples, and quickly searching through errors.

But humans can sense context in a way no machine, to this day, has been able.

Also I see it highly unlikely that a person can understand the output of an agent, if they aren't familiar with the work itself.

Agents are more like assistants. The complement, not substitute, an already capable professional.

This professionals often have to steer the wheel, so the agent looks elsewhere, and it doesn't continue looping into nonsense.

kypro

8 hours ago

I find this hard to believe. What are you doing and what AI tools are you using?

atleastoptimal

9 hours ago

IMO the best path is global regulation on frontier AI development with high penalties for defection that, detectable and enforced by member states, independent agencies and broad public support.

platevoltage

an hour ago

I'm doing my very best to not let my skills atrophy. I have gotten a lot of benefit from AI in certain cases. I co-own a SaaS with a TON of tech debt, and AI has been helpful for reducing some of the tedium of migrating through 3 Django versions, but I will never be one of those people who brags about "not opening an IDE in 6 months" like I recently saw on this board.

kypro

7 hours ago

We're opening Pandora's box. I think outside of global coordination against large training runs (backed with military force) it's too late at this point. Failing that, without some massive geopolitical event, progress will continue.

Given this, I think doom is now almost certain, but there are 3-levels of doom, including one you can prep for, and one you can prep to not partake in.

We're not going to control it, we're not going to slow the pace. We might be able to bring it to a halt if people in power get extremely serious very fast, but we're so far from that that realistically it's not happening.

Sorry.