I don’t know anything about astrology. But, just as a curiousity, I plugged the birth times and lat lons of my wife and I into a frontier model and asked it to generate our charts and personality profiles. Then, created 3 more from random inputs. 5 people who know us well (including us) independently guessed correctly. I’m sure there was information leakage. If anything, it was a fun game. But kind of eerie.
That explains things. "The stars told me to do it" would be a more coherent thesis than what they posted.
Hi, OP here.
I sat with this for a bit, and I was going to ignore this, but my wife's honor is on the line, so I just can't.
Frankly, whatever attempt at ad hominem here is uncalled for, and not befitting for HN.
My wife built a product over two years ago and hit a massive need after over a year of crawling over broken glass. I had recently left my previous startup and was going to take a break. But she needed my help. There was one week where ChatGPT's custom GPTs had terrible uptime, so she asked me to built an actual web app. And that's how I was recruited.
I was skeptical at first, given I don't believe in astrology, but I believe in the results. Not a week goes by that a user doesn't reach out to us to let us know that Star Path has had a massively positive impact on their life. Star Path has saved marriages, helped users gain the confidence to start the career they've always wanted, and more.
I also studied applied math and economics at Yale (where I met my wife, actually!), and have been investing and building software for 20 years, as both a founder and engineer.
Anyways, I'd love to keep the conversation and debate focused on the points I made, and not whatever preconceptions you might have re: astrology. Thanks.
How is your wife relevant to the conversation? No one even mentioned her on this thread or knew of her existence before you somehow decided her honor was being smeared.
Because you are insulting her. You conveniently cut out the part of my bio where I explain she's the reason I'm working on this business.
Now, your turn: how is the startup I'm building relevant to the conversation?
Note that I didn't mention your wife at all, nor did I pass any value judgement about your beliefs or profession. Any offence you took was due to your own insecurities, and getting hyper defensive about it isn't helping make your case.
I do think it's very relevant to bring up someone's background, education, profession, beliefs and more when deciding whether to make a life-changing decision based on their advice. I'm sure there are >0 people who are thinking about selling their stock portfolios right now, and this post might be the one to tip them over. They deserve to know whether you are a financial analyst or an AI founder, and whether your own decision was made fully analytically or based on the position of the planets and stars.
You cherry-picked text from my about page on my personal website, then vaguely suggested for readers to "dig into the author's credibility and credentials", and now you're trying to act as if you're not engaging in ad hominem.
Like I suggested earlier in this thread: please engage with my points if you have a well-reasoned critique, which, as it seems, you do not.
If I am reading a blog post written by an MD about medical advice or whatever, then their next post is extolling the virtues of alchemy, it IS going to make me question everything else they have said, regardless of their professional credentials. Like, maybe you are able to encapsulate and separate the real from the pseudo-science, but it at least welcomes closer scrutiny.
I did not read the article yet but adhominem attacks is against what I thought this community stood for. It even saddens me more that you suffer this because you worked with your wife. Not all nerds are like this, take heart.
I used to think the same but if the moon can affect tides, why can’t it affect humans.
I mean the mechanism there is not a mystery. Gravity is known to affect humans.
Nevertheless, IMO the placebo effect is still an effect.
That's the thing, you're calling it a placebo effect when there is a clear mechanism. I'd rather say I don't know and it could be interesting if true.