Is society growing stupider? The clues are simple and repeated

12 pointsposted 10 hours ago
by pseudolus

11 Comments

Terr_

9 hours ago

> Take the Netflix film “Irish Wish,”

So I went and checked, and it really is a ~90-minute thing, but I wonder if the excessive-exposition could partly be explained by habits (or cancelled plans) involving multi-part TV shows, where it's less-weird to remind viewers of details that might be--in their own timeline--a week in the past.

> According to actor Matt Damon, filmmakers are told: “It wouldn’t be terrible if you reiterated the plot three or four times in the dialogue, because people are on their phones while they’re watching.”

OK, well, that's just depressing... or at least, the idea that someone is being distracted playing on their phone while watching the movie on a larger screen is depressing.

In contrast, if it means people are watching on their phones while riding the bus or whatever, and distracted by external events... That's not so bad, because it's a story of where people watch rather than their (in)ability to focus.

tough

9 hours ago

I have some random Apple TV Show on the bg TV (i havent payed attention to any of it for 3 episodes)

multi-device life is a reality, something playing doesnt meant something is being watched in a world where a human can have several screens around

I do not think TV/Movies should be adapted for this reality, its up to me as a user to decide what to pay attention to, and its up to the creator to decide how to try and capture it

_aavaa_

9 hours ago

Not a week goes by without thinking about Queen’s Radio Ga Ga and how it is even more applicable now than it was then.

BeratnaGas

10 hours ago

The "simple/simplified" theme here is repeated numerous times without much insight or exploration. Tragically beyond ironic.

Terr_

9 hours ago

> without much insight or exploration

That seems a little unfair, given that we're seeing an essay to sell a much lengthier book. Some brevity is probably the author being strategic rather than un-self-aware.

Also, several of the claims do contain links for more information, such as simplification in music lyrics [0], melodies [1], and sentence-length in books [2].

[0] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-024-55742-x

[1] https://www.seresearch.qmul.ac.uk/chcc/news/4763/study-finds...

[2] https://www.economist.com/culture/2025/09/04/is-the-decline-...

mikeaskew4

10 hours ago

That’s how The Ghost operates now.

user

9 hours ago

[deleted]

bootlegbourdain

10 hours ago

Neon yellow journalism and book promo! I bet this guy has a newsletter.

abstractspoon

4 hours ago

It's why I don't watch any mainstream TV shows. They just have no subtlety. No wonder people are distracted. There's nothing to engage them.