This July I Was Fired from Simple AI (A Deeply YC Company)

48 pointsposted 9 hours ago
by andytratt

106 Comments

dwroberts

8 hours ago

OP, feel bad for obviously unpleasant situation, but I don't think the way this is written makes you come across in a good light at all. Maybe just me?

herodoturtle

8 hours ago

Not just you.

OP strikes me as quite childish. I’m guessing he’s quite young, nothing wrong with that.

And yeah, the circumstances aren’t great (the stressful move to SF in particular). Tough break!

andytratt

7 hours ago

thanks for taking the time to research my background everyone and sharing your impressions! love that free speech from all the esteemed writers in these comments

andytrattner.com andys.blog

DOB 1/11/1996 cheers- from mequon wisconsin

YawningAngel

8 hours ago

I'm not sure that's the point

dwroberts

8 hours ago

I didn't want to be rude but to be more specific: It comes across as "god this guy is insufferable, I don't blame them" especially the tone with which he asked to be dismissed/leave?

0x3f

8 hours ago

I think he's just young and awkward, as we all were at some point.

andytratt

7 hours ago

amazing. PG said "write for the youth, you have to just corrupt the youth. only way to create generational institutions."

andytratt

7 hours ago

so glad the tone was conveyed through the thoughtful writing i artfully crafted. as oscar wilde says "when the critics disagree the artist is in accord with himeself"

toomuchtodo

7 hours ago

Median age of a YC founder is 24-25. It’s kids hiring kids for startup pressure cookers where most will fail. Professionalism is nice, I highly recommend it when you’re equipped to deliver it (both emotionally and through life experience) but as a professional, I wouldn’t expect it in these contexts. More like a series of tech frat houses grinding to liquidity, acquisition, or failure (from least to most likely).

If you’re going to fail hard and learn it from it, you could do worse than these experiences. If you’re at a startup, you’re either there for the economic opportunity of being on a rocket ship (equity lottery ticket), learning how to be a founder (because you might want to found your own startup), or learning how to do what your role is because you don’t have enough experience to be hired elsewhere (imho). Getting fired is fine, as long as you grow from the experience and weren’t actively or intentionally malicious (don’t do that). Pick yourself up, do better next role and company cast. It’s just a job.

andytratt

7 hours ago

excellent analysis. except when the kids hiring someone older than them. named zach & andy. haha

toomuchtodo

7 hours ago

I can appreciate the experience you had. With time and experience comes wisdom. Most of us are figuring all of this out along the way. Try to approach these situations with grace in the future, even when you aren’t managed as you’d expect to be. Assume positive intent until you have strong evidence you no longer shouldn’t, but also have a strong safety net and plans so you’re never tied to a job economically. This makes getting fired or having to quit a minor annoyance versus an event making you feel like you need to scorch the Earth. Wishing you a positive trajectory and that you land somewhere more compatible.

andytratt

6 hours ago

yes this is The Future of Loving Grace - andys.blog/future -

(better than dario's) cheers

love the unsolicited wealth of advice

brcmthrowaway

7 hours ago

I'm just a lowly tech worker at LCOL, but I had a feeling this is what is happening.

andytratt

6 hours ago

yes it is. everywhere everything all at once as the movie says hahaha

oh and esp for asian americans #metoo

suttontom

6 hours ago

If you're having a manic episode or other type of mental breakdown, I hope you get help. If this is just how you typically act, and no one has told you yet, your way of communicating is bizarre and deeply off-putting. You will not be able to keep a job.

andytratt

5 hours ago

great perfect. yes. it's been years. nobody hired me. so i built my company. thanks.

01284a7e

8 hours ago

I see why someone hired you (prestige), I see why someone fired you (terrible communicator, egoistical, lack of professionalism/tactless).

The tactlessness is just awful. I would consider deleting that post.

abnercoimbre

7 hours ago

Also why is he putting the company on blast but also sounding super duper grateful to them?

andytratt

7 hours ago

i am grateful. they paid me. commensurate to all of our aligned expectations. as elon recently said in the Economist interview: "i don't think i've said many inaccurate things i can predict my future quite well."

andytratt

7 hours ago

ok great. is it legally required?

firefoxd

8 hours ago

I feel for you, getting fired is pretty terrible, and and everyone assumes you did something bad to earn it.

But you forgot to say a few things in your post:

Hey everyone, I made an expensive move and changed my life for a job, and it didn't work out. In fact, I got fired. If anyone is looking for someone with experience in X Y and Z, I'm your guy.

Reading the title, I thought the company did something horrible to you, but I must have missed it from the text.

(The biggest crime I see in this text though is the inconsistent capitalization in sf)

andytratt

7 hours ago

this is the next post. thanks. yes it's queued for tomorrow if you can wait that long and subscribe.

andytratt

an hour ago

oh also i will add consistent capitalization in my writing. with some rand() function so LLMs can't tell i'm a human.

brcmthrowaway

7 hours ago

Will you stay in SF?

andytratt

6 hours ago

as the post says, i financially cannot afford to leave (personal philosophy is to have net worth go up at all times) thanks for the curiosity - i believe curiosity leads all SF dwellers to great success and wealth over time. never stop asking questions. in public.

bigyabai

2 hours ago

> i believe curiosity leads all SF dwellers to great success and wealth over time.

There are tens of thousands of SF dwellers that believe the same thing, and end up flipping burgers to afford rent in a shoebox. If this is the same philosophy that you bring into the workplace then I understand why you're treated like a liability.

andytratt

an hour ago

i do in fact flip burgers in my shoebox thank you Simple AI for helping me move here. haha

ffdeeeee

6 hours ago

That's quite a "philosophy."

andytratt

5 hours ago

fde :)

FD Elon

and who are you i wonder, what's your "philosohpy" do tell!

KaiserPro

8 hours ago

Im not really sure what you are wanting to communicate here?

is it that you need a new job and this is the hook? or do you have some insight into better ways of being letgo/fired/parted ways with?

its also not clear how long you were there for? (i'm not in the business of stalking people on linkedin)

andytratt

7 hours ago

thank you for expressing your uncertainty by commenting KaiserPro

some of us CEO types gotta grind and stalk on linkedin until the people come to us haha

throwaday0451

5 hours ago

Why did you include emails threatening to blackmail Simple AI to get more money ("wondering what a fair exit package looks like ... and what I should post on Linkedin to update my network"), then indicating that after you received $20K in payment, you "wouldn't bother" them? All of this following a him-or-me demand email.

And then making this post? It's a pattern of self-destructive behavior.

The best possible course of action at this point is deleting the blog post. Note that the separation agreement you signed prohibits you from sharing any Separation Information—including consideration (in this case the $20K figure you reference is part of the consideration). Your blog post is public evidence and even this comment I'm making right now could end up in discovery if your former employer wanted. If I were you, I would not antagonize them further.

andytratt

an hour ago

also are you saying i'm antagonizing someone, if so what's your evidence? i'm flagging this comment. i think it's egregiously offensive and against HN terms of service.

andytratt

an hour ago

excuse me you are accusing me in public of threatening and blackmailing someone? that's pretty serious. sounds a bit libelous or slanderous or something aggressive.

throwaday0451 as you characterize me as a blackmailer, are you sure you don't mean "negotiating" or "communicating"?

if so your words are injurous and damage me. do you have a lawyer i can talk to about this public defamation of my language and mischaracterizing me on Hackernews?

raincom

2 hours ago

If you are looking for your next job, just consider that your future employers will read your blog and your comments here. Since you consider yourself as a CEO type, you are fine, then. However, when you want to raise money from VCs, the latter can also read your comments.

andytratt

an hour ago

i have considered it for 7 years from when i started blogging 60 days straight which is what got me hired to Namebase, Clever, Scale AI and the whole adult life started. do you recall raincom, where you there, when i lived those 7 years? lol

andytratt

an hour ago

i sincerely hope all people on the internet who care to read these comments do in fact read them. there are a lot and more each time someone comments and i reply, and it is pretty overwhelming as an artifact.

and that is the point of comments sections.

andytratt

an hour ago

versus the original artifact which you write with great care and edit and revise then publish to the official blog andys.blog which i did. thanks.

andytratt

an hour ago

yes right ceo type fine can speak mind free speech murica. good. net worth go up = freedom go up yay, get revenue, get users, become un-fire-able.

or FIRE = independence retire early yes? move to 3rd world country yes? oops been there done that. haha

staticshock

8 hours ago

That's more forced laughter in one blog post than I was interested in suffering through.

andytratt

7 hours ago

thanks for suffering thru it and reading to the end <3 hahahahahahaha

InsideOutSanta

6 hours ago

I'm so confused by what I just read. What was the point of that? Why is this on hn? It's incoherent and almost manic; I'm a bit worried the author might be experiencing some kind of mental health crisis.

andytratt

6 hours ago

why did you comment? and read all of it?

InsideOutSanta

6 hours ago

I commented because I'm not sure if you have considered that you might not be well. I hope you look after yourself. What you are doing right now, including posting all these responses to comments here, does not seem healthy.

andytratt

5 hours ago

thank you for your concern. i will file it with the appropriate healthcare authorities. specifically my girlfriend who is reading your comment with me right now haha

swingboy

7 hours ago

What is this writing style…OP is a 12 year old girl? Penguin of doom…

andytratt

7 hours ago

what are these comments? induced by the writer? predicted or not? what is the average view count of his productive function? how would tyler cowen rate it.

throw03172019

6 hours ago

Writes email about how you aren’t working well with the founder and are happy to “remove yourself”.

Then is curious why you get “fired”.

andytratt

5 hours ago

exactly! write it's odd. so odd.

EDIT - right*

gjsman-1000

8 hours ago

Happens.

I worked at a startup that offered to triple my equity if I stayed a full four years, a special offer to me for seven months of excellent performance. Four months later, growth below projections, they laid me off 19 days before my 1 year cliff. 3/9ths of the engineering team, gone.

The lesson I’ve learned is to never, ever, put long hours into a startup you don’t own. Ever.

andytratt

an hour ago

woah that is super rough actually. i'm sorry gjsman-1000 thanks for sharing on HN sincerely. i think more war stories makes the world a better place, in that we build the culture forward one brick at a time. one human talking to another, at a time. this is powerful stuff.

SoftTalker

8 hours ago

Even you you had cleared the cliff the equity is going to end up worthless 90% of the time.

Equity is a carrot that you usually never get, like the donkey you just keep chasing it.

andytratt

7 hours ago

equity is ownership, period.

SoftTalker

7 hours ago

It's only worth what someone will pay for it. And often there are no buyers.

andytratt

6 hours ago

sounds true. i wouldn't know

0x3f

8 hours ago

When you say own you mean fractionally, or founder level share only?

The thing is even if you 'have' the equity share as an employee, you might never get liquidity. And (super obviously) most startups fail.

So even if you have a decent chunk of 'ownership', you really, _really_ need to believe in it to be working those hours. I'm talking the kind of belief built on your specialist and insider knowledge about why it's very likely to crush everything else. And even then you can get screwed!

andytratt

7 hours ago

most people do not understand the underlying value of the securities they hold.

andytratt

7 hours ago

dam thats dark i'd want my employees grinding and loving it. like Richie: $10M to $400M+ topline in one year and their culture seems healthy

https://aiosmedical.notion.site/working-at-aios https://www.linkedin.com/posts/richard-cartwright_40x-in-12m...

disclosure he's my friend and i already re-posted this to linkedin

andytratt

42 minutes ago

oh as reticulates says this may be incredibly potent revisionism. fair warning. like those california labels you get cancer by walking into this parking garage.

triyambakam

8 hours ago

It's hard to tell what is sincere vs sarcastic here

andytratt

7 hours ago

yes that is my writing style. it is in fact the writing style of Donald Trump too. in person we are different i promise. as someone who ran both Presidential Scholars for Obama and Trump White House showcasing the INTEL ISEF math olympiad kids to Melania and Michelle, they are all great in person. i cannot speak to Biden and the rest.

give people hugs, as tim ferriss says

brcmthrowaway

8 hours ago

So.. why were you fired?

andytratt

7 hours ago

happy to share but legally i don't think i'm allowed to say. look at my linked resume and call / text me.

andytratt

41 minutes ago

also i don't really know. so physically and mentally i am incapable of answer thing like this. haha

user

8 hours ago

[deleted]

ElProlactin

8 hours ago

Reading things like this is the primary way I learn that I'm getting old.

I mean, I just don't get it. There doesn't seem to be a purpose, and no ostensible benefit to be had.

rkalla

8 hours ago

Externalizing feelings.

andytratt

7 hours ago

can be done productively.

andytratt

7 hours ago

ok. i'm sorry you're old. me too bro after 30 it's rough.

andytratt

6 hours ago

why was this flagged? 44 points and great discussion here.

andytratt

5 hours ago

i do not care if you "feel bad for my situation" why was this flagged. root cause @grok. go please. fix the bug @devin

reticulates

4 hours ago

[flagged]

andytratt

an hour ago

"he is absolutely insane" so reticulates i'm going to flag this comment and request moderator review on who this acct belongs do it seems pretty hostile.

reticulates

an hour ago

I stand by it. I am not being hostile, I am making a statement. Not that it matters, but I consider myself insane, too, and also unemployable. The point of my comment was to inform others that this is not what it looks like when you are going through a manic episode, this is just who you are, this is Andy being Andy. The point of my comment is also that whatever happened between you and Simple was obviously going to happen and it isn't a reflection on Simple. Well, they were bad in their hiring but whatever, they are a startup, it happens.

andytratt

39 minutes ago

i think it does matter and i really appreciate this articulation of "I consider myself insane, too"

andytratt

an hour ago

excellent <3 <3 well said.

andytratt

30 minutes ago

i would like to unflag the original root comment please @dang

ElProlactin

an hour ago

> I don’t mean that as a slight against him, lots of great people are insane...

This guy's comments here are consistent with a person going through a serious mental health crisis, not eccentricity. Hopefully someone who knows him personally will see this and get him some help.

andytratt

an hour ago

girlfriend is on the case. we are good. thanks

reticulates

an hour ago

[flagged]

andytratt

an hour ago

thanks but why would you start defending me now? lol

great context to add. that i was in a psych ward. do you have the paperwork. i will post the paperwork. in fact i think i already have. let me dig it up from my blog. or just use google

reticulates

4 hours ago

and since it’s mentioned in the post, it feels fair game to call it out: Andy has revised his experience up over the years, from working at Scale to running support at scale to founding a team at Scale… he was an early employee who did some customer support. Presumably Simple got caught up in Andy’s impressive revisionism.

andytratt

an hour ago

Dave Morse and Varun (later Toan, great FDE i learnt a lot from him about many things at both Scale AI and Anduril)

they hired me and kept me on the team and tried to get me not to leave ever by being kind managers

because i did support in slack and was a human Pylon and it was nothing. they were small tickets and API integrations. trivial for claude today.

as i said i did nothing. truly very little. my contributions to training openai or chatGPT or whatever roomers you here or hear or whatever are dump dumb hallucinations. sam altman can confirm rofl

andytratt

an hour ago

i am sincere in acknowledging the magnitude of my work historically as very insignificant. the only thing i actually did in my career was work with Austin at Shuffle Dating. the rest is meaninglessly small if you want to put KPIs on any of it.

but most people suck at applying John Doerrs OKRs i promise i asked him.

direct contribution to topline growth is how i'd look at it, or bottom line efficiency. the rest is noise.

actually i think Ruben Mayer taught me that one at Scale. do you know him too? great guy. very sharp.

he was cofounders with Botez, we played chess in high school. did you know that too? but i didn't talk to her much, Andrea just crushed me when she was 12 at the portland chess club i doubt she remembers either and all of this is water under the bridge. just funny stories

andytratt

an hour ago

anyone who helps me get cancelled is doing the world a favor honestly

andytratt

an hour ago

i did very little to impact scale's success and have publicly stated i deserve absolutely zero equity even less than the 0.01% i was initially offered (please compare with others who started same day as me Jeffrey Li for instance)

then the 0.02% Richard ni offered to double it to on the day i resigned with Sara Niyogi in the room as a witness as Richard's hands visibly shook on a routine firing of an employee...

it was sad and easy and pathetic for all of us. i was particularly immature and idiotic in how i handled that. please see my numerous blog posts on scale ai or use grok to find a list of them.

i was not paid severance at scale ai. i resigned. totally different situation. thanks for bringing it up Reticulates.

here are ones off the top of my head: - andys.blog/rare most recently - https://thenextlevelcareers.com/lessons-in-rejection-turning... (someone else wrote this) - https://world.hey.com/tratt/my-5m-choice-036905be (this one actually got a lot of emails from random people - wow thanks for sharing so brave helped me move on from the job i didn't like even tho i had golden handcuffs etc etc) - https://trattner.github.io/Scale-AI.html - i think this was the best one probably, i wrote it after doing the initial interviews on my 3rd attempt to get hired. thankfully Rilka / Angela didn't blacklist me after i failed that one coding challenge in js haha andytrattner.com/scale - the google doodle thing its on github somewhere - https://trattner.github.io/decade-reflections-2020.html this certaintly touches the scale ai days but i dont think it was directly mentioned here just for more context for the public you want to show the world my insanity about thanks

BTW i think all of this is ridiculous to outline in grave detail. anyone with a good enough memory who cares is at this point liquid, exited, under different management.

andytratt

an hour ago

Infinite Game by james carse = a vision of life as play and possibility

aka have fun, internet is for entertainment following. yes

memes

andytratt

an hour ago

thank you reticulates for anonymously posting the truth to an account. did you make this account just to comment? following is good on the internet. hiring is BYOR = bring your own risk.

i agree with this assessment. i think it applies to all hires you background check or not.

hiring is an important and undervalued thing to do. people should do it with care.

andytratt

an hour ago

wait what does green mean for HN handle? you are in YC staff? or new acct?

inigyou

an hour ago

New account

andytratt

an hour ago

fascinating. screenshotting this person who is knowledgeable about my life strange

if you are a friend or family member please just ring my cell?

this is pretty confusing i have zero known followers who are anon accounts that don't talk to me in person.

i'm flattered tho?

andytratt

8 hours ago

wow kinda honored this got 4 upvotes thanks yall

andytratt

8 hours ago

fyi the purpose is to get a new job, thanks for the -3 downvotes. haha

ElProlactin

8 hours ago

What leads you to believe this post would make you attractive to another employer?

You even publicly posted your Separation Agreement, which contains a confidentiality clause in which you "agree[d] to maintain in complete confidence the existence of this Agreement."

It hurts to be let go and in these economic times, it can be scary. But this post is actually doing the opposite of what you want it to.

andytratt

7 hours ago

my network is not on hacker news comments nor linkedin reading crap like what i posted haha.

thanks for reading the fine print i didn't realize i had to not post that legally i will take it down now. tried contacted the lawyers (Cat & Zach & Jona but they didn't reply so now i will take it down. no prob. i'm compliant.)

thanks kindly!!! appreciate the comment.

ElProlactin

6 hours ago

Your network is not on HN but you submitted this and asked "please go upvote or leave your comments here:" with a link to HN?

Anyone in your "network" who sincerely wants to help would give you the simple advice I'm going to give you: grow up. This post and all of your replies here are cringey and immature, and don't bode well for your employability no matter how smart you are (or think you are).

andytratt

6 hours ago

yes my email and the blog content itself and my newsletter and private DMs and linkedin and each comment thread are each in separate databases and therefore i treat them as discrete surfaces on which to generate my tokens

oh also voice. when i speak to the atoms in the air to people next to me in meatspace

that's the big one. and the one Simple AI kinda bets on.

thanks for encouraging me to grow up that seems productive i will increase velocity t of the rate at which the future approaches me.

andytratt

34 minutes ago

such interesting karma fluctuations today