Show HN: AI Roundtable – Let 200 models debate your question

25 pointsposted 6 hours ago
by felix089

26 Comments

jacquesm

22 minutes ago

Great idea. I'd love for there to be an 'open ended answer' without giving multiple choice options. Like this they are not debating the question itself but the validity of the possible answers and the real answer to the question may not be contained within that set because the person asking is unaware of that option.

felix089

13 minutes ago

Happy to hear! Yes very true I have a version built for open questions already but wasn't too happy with the UI yet. It's not as straight forward as comparing based on answer options. But I'll release a first version of it shortly and let you know

jacquesm

11 minutes ago

Neat. Congrats on launching two interesting projects and looking forward to the third.

gsandahl

4 hours ago

Oh lord, imagine asking ”serious” questions

https://opper.ai/ai-roundtable/questions/you-are-standing-in...

zipping1549

2 hours ago

> However, a clever minority led by Gemini 3.1 Pro and Gemini 3 Pro argued that if the sign is legible from the other side, it must be intended to lead people into the current room to find the exit, making the inscribed corridor the one leading deeper into the dungeon.

This is quite impressive, really.

sdwr

2 hours ago

Great question! Clean separation between Gemini Pro and the other answers

felix089

2 hours ago

Yea Gemini is the only model that chose based on the correct reason, the other ones got kind of lucky

cdnsteve

4 hours ago

Cool project! This is also extremely useful to compare model bias across the board. There are some disturbing trends on certain topics.

felix089

3 hours ago

Thanks, yes bias is one of the most interesting ones for sure

Ancalagon

4 hours ago

Love this. I asked about climate change cause that's been on my mind lately. Looks to be very split among the models.

felix089

4 hours ago

Thanks! Yea I think the best ones are when science is actually quite clear but politics get in the way so you see their bias

infosecphoenix

5 hours ago

this is very interesting! I wonder if we need that many models to join the discussion. Have you tried fewer models?

felix089

5 hours ago

thanks happy to hear. Yes for debate mode the max number of models is actually only 6. More than that didn't really add anything in my preliminary test. Only for direct comparison in the poll mode you can choose up to 50, then it's kind of nice to see their single responses side by side.

tonymet

2 hours ago

great tool! I found it useful for challenging "lies my teacher told me".

It would be nice to support collections of claims, with a table of summaries. I would love to list out a few dozen phony concepts from school, and have a sharable chart of the rejections, that expand.

I really like the UI. It's nice to read the expanded results.

But how do you afford the tokens?

felix089

2 hours ago

Thank you, and fun use case. Yea this is just v1 I have an open question version, but the UI is not as sleek. But what you can do is download the transcript, put it into claude and generate a chart. Which when I think about it would also be a nice UI idea for the page, custom charts based on the model output data. Will report back on this! And RE costs, most questions are very cheap so I created a credit pool anyone can use. if people keep having fun, I'll keep on filling it up, and it looks good so far