Tech CEOs attend Amazon-funded "Melania" screening at White House

150 pointsposted 12 days ago
by camillomiller

69 Comments

gdubs

12 days ago

Long way from the "Think Different" era Apple. Been thinking about that campaign this week. Posters of people like MLK, which Jobs had to get permission for from each and every estate for the campaign. When Apple was solidly, unambiguously positioned as the computer for the rebels, the misfits, the crazy ones.

If nothing else, there was an opportunity to simply say that given the day's events, a movie screening didn't feel right. Or – "hey there's a gigantic winter storm covering half the country, and I have a lot of logistical stuff to take care of."

JuniperMesos

11 days ago

> Long way from the "Think Different" era Apple. Been thinking about that campaign this week. Posters of people like MLK, which Jobs had to get permission for from each and every estate for the campaign. When Apple was solidly, unambiguously positioned as the computer for the rebels, the misfits, the crazy ones.

"Think Different" was an advertising slogan that Apple Computers, a publicly-traded corporation with thousands of employees, paid an advertising company to create in the late 90s in order to promote a certain image of the company, because the leadership at the time thought it would help them sell more computers. And it clearly worked (or at least didn't abjectly fail) because Apple Computers is still around today and is an even larger corporate entity with a much larger market cap.

Whether a marketing campaign succeeds in appealing to you emotionally has nothing to do with whether rebels, misfits, crazy people, or any other category of person would be better off buying and using computer products made by Apple. I've personally never liked Apple products, I've always felt like they took a lot of practical control away from the end user in order to facilitate what Apple leadership thinks the end user _ought_ to want. So I avoid using their products, and I think other people should to, although I respect that the walled garden Apple provides is a computing product some people do find it useful to pay for.

Leadership at Apple computer was probably engaging in political activities some people at the time objected to when those ads were made, just as they are today.

bigyabai

11 days ago

I dunno. I also think about how Jobs swindled and mistreated Woz time after time, many of the nerds who cut their teeth on the Apple IIc were appalled by the road he took. By the time the Macintosh released, Apple had cemented themselves as a capricious OEM with no interest in serving every minority niche.

Actions like this feel fully contiguous with Jobs' personality, to me. He wasn't afraid to mistreat large swathes of customers, fans or employees if it meant that Apple could cosmetically pull ahead of it's competitors. He didn't feel obligated to fight fair or defend his moral righteousness, and neither does Cook. This is the exact same Apple you always knew, they've just quit virtue signalling.

treetalker

12 days ago

Please, God, let Mel Brooks make one more film after Spaceballs 2.

zmmmmm

12 days ago

All I can say is remember. Remember the hypocrisy, the spineless lack of values, the willingness to engage, effectively, in corruption. That should be the permanent understanding you now have of these people.

Next time they are up on stage telling you how great their new product or service is - make sure your first thought is, the person selling me this put corruptly pandering to an authoritarian wannabe dictator ahead of their own integrity. If they have no integrity, why should I trust anything they say about this product they are now pitching to me?

sillyfluke

12 days ago

It's kind of wild that the founder of this venerable company shared the same stage with Khashoggi's fiance pre-Covid.

It's like attending a memorial of an assasinated Belarus activist and then following it up by attending the premiere of a propaganda movie about Putin's wife.

Someone inside Amazon should keep tabs on the actual non-inflated viewing numbers of this amazing blockbuster for posterity's sake.

Edit: Bezos is not listed as attending (elsewhere Tony Robbins and Mike Tyson are)

camillomiller

12 days ago

On the night of Alex Pretti's execution by Border Patrol, big tech CEOs think it's a great idea to show up at the preview of the most pathetic movie in existence. This goes beyond "having to seat at the table" to change things, like Tim Cook often said. This is high level simping. I am so disgusted. These are the people y'all work for.

toephu2

12 days ago

[flagged]

user

12 days ago

[deleted]

user

12 days ago

[deleted]

codyb

12 days ago

Boycott all these goobers.

deaux

12 days ago

Would be easier if half of HN didn't work for them. There's a reason why these posts get maybe 20 comments on here whereas ones showing similar allegiance to the Party by companies half of HN doesn't work at get 600.

But hey, vests too juicy.

marcuschong

12 days ago

It's interesting how people I know wouldn't work for my small startup if I, as the boss, aligned myself with such people, but are happy to work for big tech companies that do that. It's amazing what 100 levels of abstraction and money can make you do.

brailsafe

11 days ago

> It's amazing what 100 levels of abstraction and money can make you do.

I'd say it's more like the Don Draper line "that's what the money is for", but yes ultimately it's a transaction, and rarely are people doing anything at an individual level professionally that would be worth stopping because of a vague sense of guilt by distant association.

If the connection is closer and the actions you take issue with are clearly impacted by your association with them, then there may be no amount of money that's worth it.

gdilla

9 days ago

yet their million dollar TC ain't enough to have a bunker for their little family when the time comes. or when shit is mad max on the streets, that tech bus aint gonna protect you.

marcuschong

9 days ago

Right. A subterranean fortress in NZ is not part of the perks.

gdilla

7 days ago

they may be allowed as part of the help staff! but only limited spots.

llbbdd

12 days ago

and/or come up with some kind of civil disobedience that isn't some antiquated waste of time. boycott? why not just pray about it and see if that works?

codyb

12 days ago

You don't think boycotts work? You should ask Target how they feel about that comment.

And, amazingly enough, "boycott all these goobers" is not the _only thing_ in the world a person can do at once.

But sure, keep hurling money at people you despise while talking about how others should do better.

JohnFen

12 days ago

> "boycott all these goobers" is not the _only thing_ in the world a person can do at once.

This.

Boycotts can be effective and important tools, but they aren't sufficient all by themselves. No tool is.

llbbdd

11 days ago

But they aren't. Weren't the same people boycotting like Starbucks and McDonalds recently over the kerfuffle with Israel? Last I checked neither of those gigantic companies reacted to that at all except for firing people and shutting down stores that were already underperforming, if that was the goal of the boycott then they nailed it.

codyb

10 days ago

I mean... companies downsizing because people aren't buying enough of their products is exactly the point of a boycott lol.

llbbdd

11 days ago

Target? They're down a miniscule amount from record breaking revenue in 2021, which looks a lot more like a correction in line with the rest of the market around tariffs and other uncertainty. I hadn't heard of this boycott at all, which is part of my point. Boycotts only inconvenience the people performatively taking part in them, Target is on a very different timeline and does not care.

7e

12 days ago

What could possibly be in this movie other than Melania constantly suing news outlets who ran reports she was a sex worker?

duxup

12 days ago

I was on a website and got a “sign Melania’s birthday card” advertisement. Super creepy.

Trasmatta

12 days ago

So many apologists for Tim Apple over the past year, but I think this is just who he is. Gladly embracing fascism and authoritarianism.

codyb

12 days ago

Yea, Apple's decision to have its CEO embrace fascism has really destroyed a ton of my goodwill towards the company and I'm actively looking for alternatives, delaying further purchases, and encouraging others to do the same.

Doesn't help that they appear to have shot all of their UX designers into the sun judging by the most recent iOS and MacOS upgrades.

bigyabai

12 days ago

Don't forget that he did it for Trump's first admin too. Cooperation with the government seems to be an imperative beyond the CEO's control.

iJohnDoe

12 days ago

Very true. This is why Hitler was surrounded by so many people. They went where the power was. Even if it’s not “who he is”, it is who he became.

The nazis were prosecuted decades later. Tim Cook’s actions shouldn’t be magically forgotten once Trump is out of office.

This pattern has historical precedent. Adolf Hitler’s inner circle included people like Albert Speer, a trained architect who was not an early ideologue but aligned himself with power as the regime consolidated control. Speer benefited professionally, became Minister of Armaments, and later claimed political detachment. These claims were rejected at Nuremberg, where he was convicted for his role in the Nazi state.

The fact that alignment can be opportunistic rather than ideological did not absolve responsibility then, and it should not automatically do so now. Accountability is not erased simply because a political era ends.

dissent

12 days ago

There's a big difference between being a party member actually in a government position (war related, no less), and being a businessman surviving under that regime. You're not only making an absurd comparison, you're calling for punishment for somebody who hasn't even remotely broken any laws. Can't you see you're being authoritarian?

politelemon

12 days ago

Law and morality are not the same thing. The apologism for Apple on HN is comically and selectively gymnastics. I think the biggest shame here is the brand identity for a corporation that many of you have self deluded into adopting. Even now the voices that tell you to stop bootlicking them and warning against them get shouted down.

dissent

12 days ago

That may be true, but if you think your definition of morality is correct and anybody who thinks otherwise needs to be punished, then no wonder you've ended up with an authoritarian who's beaten you at your own game.

It's also got nothing to do with Apple fanboyism. The same is true for all corporations in the US.

brewdad

9 days ago

When the opposite side of the coin is Trumpism, yeah, I’m going with my definition of morality is correct. It isn’t perfect but it sure beats the alternative.

user

6 days ago

[deleted]

dpkirchner

12 days ago

Somehow I doubt Tim Cook would have trouble surviving if he did not choose to bend the knee.

dissent

12 days ago

He might be lynched by his shareholders :)

fireflash38

7 days ago

It's why Hugo Boss is only a footnote in history for being a huge part of the Nazi regime right? Right?

Nope. Other way around. Their Nazi support is a footnote in their Wikipedia page.

dissent

7 days ago

Come on, it was the 1930s, in Germany and Hitler and the Nazis (the real ones we got the name from) were actually in power. You're comparing apples to potatoes.

fireflash38

5 days ago

In some German dialects, "potato" is translated as "earth apple".

So yeah, I am comparing apples and potatoes.

We are living under a fascist regime.

JohnFen

12 days ago

> Even if it’s not “who he is”

We are what we do.

deepfriedchokes

12 days ago

Capitalists only care about capital. Witness how fast the DEI stuff was jettisoned once it was determined to be unprofitable under the current administration.

JuniperMesos

11 days ago

DEI programs were (largely) incentivized by one political faction in the United States primarily via legal rather than market mechanisms, and in response to this a rival political faction explicitly ran on undoing those legal mechanisms to disincentivize DEI programs.

Of course one of the ways the government can enact policy is by making something cheap or expensive for firms participating in capitalism to do, which incentivizes their behavior; but characterizing DEI programs as something that corporations jettisoned because it was determined to be "unprofitable under the current administration" ignores the fact that the current administration explicitly promised to end DEI programs in a political campaign in a democracy and then won an election.

nicbou

12 days ago

Here’s to the crazy ones

1attice

11 days ago

Wild that this post is flagged despite explicitly being about the tech industry

smrtinsert

12 days ago

It's pathetic on many levels but I cant shake the most obvious one to me, the nerds are being forced to worship the school bully and his girl

mikeyouse

12 days ago

Forced means something else when you’re among the most rich and powerful people on earth - they chose to do this. It’s far more demeaning and should haunt them to their graves.

CamperBob2

12 days ago

Bezos can afford anything on Earth, but he can't afford to alienate Trump. Tariffs could end Amazon overnight.

Same is true for Musk, whose fortune hinges on government largesse and regulatory collegiality.

But Apple? Screw those asshats, they have no such excuses.

jp_nc

12 days ago

End Amazon overnight and see what the response is from the people. What I don’t get about these guys is that they have their OWN power base - their customers. Just look at the leverage TikTok had because of their users

deaux

12 days ago

> What I don’t get about these guys is that they have their OWN power base - their customers

What do you not get about these guys? It's very simple. The likes of Tim Cook, Mark Zuckerberg, Jeff Bezos are the exact same as Peter Thiel and Elon Musk. The last two are just louder about it. They have their own power base, but relying on it doesn't maximize their wealth. In a best case scenario, they could achieve maybe 50% of the wealth by relying on their own power base, compared to kowtowing to The Party. They don't want 50%, they want 100%, and there's absolutely nothing that they won't do for it.

mayneack

12 days ago

They absolutely can afford to be a-political. It may not maximize their wealth, but they can afford a little less maximizing.

Gud

12 days ago

Donald Trump is an extreme narcissist and you are either with him or against him. There is no “a-political”.

mindslight

11 days ago

Any one of these so-called titans of industry could have stood against Trump, and then parlayed the inevitable tantrum into the launch of their own Presidential campaign. But weak men create hard times.

mikeyouse

12 days ago

I’m sure that’s what Bezos tells himself. Which is both wrong and absolutely ignominious.

And if Elon’s X feed contains his real thoughts, his brain has turned to pudding and he earnestly believes a bunch of really vile racist garbage, so I guess it makes sense he’s hanging out with the rest of the deplorables in this administration.

ofrzeta

12 days ago

> Tariffs could end Amazon overnight.

Is this really true? Tariffs can be applied only if products go inside/outside the US. They could still operate from othe locations.

com2kid

12 days ago

Each round of Chinese tariffs had an exception for smartphones.

That wasn't by chance. iPhones going up in price 50% would kill Apple very quickly.

mikeyouse

11 days ago

All phones would be subject to the same - it’s not like Pixel devices are made in West Virginia or something.

brewdad

9 days ago

Apple relies on people churning their phones every year or two far more than Google or any other Android manufacturer.

greyface-

12 days ago

> being forced to

Choosing to.

JuniperMesos

11 days ago

I'm honestly pretty tired of the 80s-movie-derived cultural memeplex of nerds getting oppressed by jocks with girlfriends in a high school context. This never accurately characterized any social environment I've been in, and I'm definitely a nerd by disposition. I'm not sure this ever really existed outside the imaginations of hollywood screenwriters. The Breakfast Club is mid, Weird Science is an actively terrible movie, and Ferris Bueller's Day Off is entertaining enough but looms way too large in the American pop culture imagination.

Tim Cook was the salutatorian of his Alabama public high school, majored in industrial engineering in college, and later got an MBA. He sold IBM computers for years and joined Apple in its late 90s doldrums because he was won over by Steve Jobs' charisma within several minutes of his first interview with Jobs. He's an openly-gay fitness nut - meaning he's had a lot of opportunity to have sex in his life (and being famously private, he's not talking about it one way or the other, as is his right).

I frankly don't think Tim Cook is much of a nerd. He's a smart, driven, ambitious business guy who's done a good job at making the gigantic electronics company he's the CEO of sell more products and navigate the political environment it operates in. He's not some underdog hero, and people who actually care about technology for its own sake or who care about computational sovereignty shouldn't attach their sense of identity to anything Apple does.

tecoholic

12 days ago

Wow. That’s a breakdown I will remember for a long time.

Supermancho

12 days ago

Adam from Adam Does Movies can't wait to do a recrap of Melania and my family is excited to see THAT.

jnaina

11 days ago

Not sure why such an interest in this poor remake of "Pretty Woman". I'd rather wait for SpaceBalls 2.

mindslight

11 days ago

Does anybody else just tacitly hash to "melanoma" ? I'm sure it's a beautiful name in the original Slovenian context, but in the US the only time he hear it is talking about someone who is in a bunch of photographs with Epstein, so it's natural to form some negative associations.

defrost

12 days ago

I'm amazed that Klemen Slakonja's First Lady Melania Trump documentary made it out of Slovenia.

It's certainly a beautiful country.

Gud

12 days ago

A friendly reminder that the western world too is ruled by oligarchs and is democratic in name only.

It is time to take control over the means of production.

troyvit

12 days ago

Oh is this the schlock they can get to play at the Trump Kennedy Center now?