bluebarbet
4 hours ago
>All of these let you use a custom domain, which you should do. Buy yourname.com. It costs ten dollars a year and your writing will live at an address you control, regardless of what happens to any particular platform.
I used to tell this to anyone who would listen. I changed my mind.
For an individual, renting and managing one's own domain is a costly PITA that gets you less than nothing in return. I've done it for a quarter of a century. The UX of DNS hasn't improved (it's still impossible for normies). Registrars' prices haven't dropped. The security hazards of artisanal hosting are more real than ever. And even if you take the hosting package, your custom domain still carries a fatal weakness: stop paying and it goes away in short order.
And for what? Your blog will be indexed by search engines wherever it is. Moreover, it will be archived by the Internet Archive wherever it is, and - let's be honest - the IA is where your writing is going to survive if anywhere at all. Custom domains are not just vain, they're ephemeral. Certainly more so than, say, the domain of a blogging platform that's managed by a non-profit.
A domain represents an ongoing maintenance commitment and cost. By definition, such things are better managed by groups than by individuals. For the purpose of a personal blog, where no financial interests are at stake, there's only one possible reason to get a custom domain: vanity.
rchaud
35 minutes ago
> A domain represents an ongoing maintenance commitment and cost.
There's no maintenance if you go with a hosted solution with custom domains like Squarespace, Wordpress.com and the like. Just as there is for everything digital, from a computer or a phone or internet service. A domain costs a lot less than any of those other prerequisites.
I agree DNS UX is absolutely terrible, but web hosting, SSL and redirects aren't trivial things so I understand why it is the way it is.
sosodev
an hour ago
> The security hazards of artisanal hosting are more real than ever
How could this possibly be true? It's not at all rocket science to create a static blog and serve it via a production grade web server (nginx, etc).
> The UX of DNS hasn't improved (it's still impossible for normies)
The UX of DNS sucks but we're talking about a single A record. Is that not within reach of a normie in the age of AI?
> Custom domains are not just vain, they're ephemeral. Certainly more so than, say, the domain of a blogging platform that's managed by a non-profit.
I can't think of a single free blogging platform that has stood up to the test of time. Depending on centralized resources, particularly when you're not paying for them, is the recipe for ephemerality. If you're going to pay for it why can't you afford a domain?
galleywest200
4 hours ago
> For an individual, renting and managing one's own domain is a costly PITA that gets you less than nothing in return.
A counterpoint: When I see someone trying to sell me professional services, and their email is some @gmail.com or similar domain I immediately think they are less professional. Getting a domain for your blog or business is useful in certain regards.
bluebarbet
3 hours ago
For a business, yes absolutely.