Show HN: Tidy Baby is a SET game but with words

30 pointsposted 19 hours ago
by brgross

6 Comments

furyofantares

16 hours ago

Really neat. Part of speech is quite easily the hardest dimension, kind of interesting to have a SET game with such a difference in the dimensions.

I'm curious about the decision to do it showing 2 words and you find the 3rd. It's trivial to identify which length and text decoration you're looking for, usually leaving only a couple options and you have to work out which one is the right part of speech. I guess that's why you're meant to level up your pacing.

But I'm surprised it's not more like the original set, where you're searching around the board for a group of 3 rather than presented with 2 that have a known 3rd that you're meant to find.

The share result is really clever. I guess maybe that answers my questions actually, it's designed around a playtime that's more like a daily puzzle game.

zahlman

16 hours ago

> Part of speech is quite easily the hardest dimension

Many English words can be used as two (or all three) of noun/verb/adjective. Including, er, "set".

> The share result is really clever. I guess maybe that answers my questions actually, it's designed around a playtime that's more like a daily puzzle game.

That's table stakes for this kind of game now. I think the main way people learned about Wordle must have been from their friends spamming their results on Discord/Twitter/etc.

furyofantares

16 hours ago

> That's table stakes for this kind of game now.

Haha, well yes - I've put quite a number of these games out myself. I was a little surprised I didn't realize at the start that it was going to be this type of game, probably because of SET being a PVP game I've played tons of (well, you can play it solo but I haven't) so I wasn't really seeing this as a daily puzzle game at first.

But anyway, some of these games do a better job with their share result than others, often depending on if it's tacked on at the end or if the game is designed with it in mind. I was commenting that I liked this specific share result.

dilap

14 hours ago

It's neat!

Suggestionms:

A version where you actually need to find sets -- "have two, find third" is way too easy.

Monospaced font -- it's too hard visually to see difference in word length right now, w/o counting letters.

zahlman

16 hours ago

> We’ve got three “paces” in the game: Steady, Strenuous, and Grueling

I hope nobody in the wagon gets dysentery.

> In Tidy Baby you only have to deal with three dimensions... two “game cards” and a grid of up to nine candidates

So it's just recognizing which candidate completes the set?

> - word length (3, 4, or 5 letters) - part of speech (noun, verb, or adjective) - style (bold, underline, or italic)

"Style" seems artificial here. Couldn't it be something else to do with the word itself?

messe

15 hours ago

> Wyna Liu (of NYT Connections!)

The blatant rip off of a round from the BBC quiz show Only Connect?