Starlink in crosshairs: How Russia could attack Elon Musk's conquering of space

4 pointsposted 15 hours ago
by pseudolus

4 Comments

bell-cot

14 hours ago

"developing a new anti-satellite weapon" seems a laughably overblown description, when the supposed weapon amounts to little more than a box full of BB's, with a couple sticks of dynamite in the middle to spread 'em out in orbit. If they had a suitable rocket ready to launch, then a good-enough warhead could probably be designed from first principles, fabricated, and launched within 24 hours.

But from a Russian PoV - considering such weapons, and leaking that fact, could be an extremely cheap and credible method of sabre-rattling.

(Vs. actually using such weapons against Musk's constellation would be a clear attack on America's interests and capabilities, and would draw a very harsh reaction. Outside of WWIII or WWIII-lite scenarios, it'd be a Bad Move.)

toomuchtodo

14 hours ago

I’d be more impressed with something that could pump enough energy into a StarLink satellite from the ground to disable it during its orbit over ground Russia (or China) controls, but I’m unsure if we’re there yet, as 550km is a lot of distance to cover with directed energy considering the short period of visibility during a pass.

https://npolicy.org/coping-with-the-ground-based-laser-asat-...

https://theprint.in/defence/these-futuristic-chinese-space-d...

bell-cot

7 hours ago

I'd assume that both China and Russia are routinely experimenting with "orbital tracking radars". Which might "accidentally" hit various satellites with overly energetic EMP pulses at times.

tehjoker

15 hours ago

i thought starlink was using a low orbit that separated it from most other objects and would cause relatively rapid decay of debris. are there other objects in that orbit we should care about?