Em Dash in Reddit Comments, Interactive

3 pointsposted 7 hours ago
by jonatron

9 Comments

carlos-menezes

6 hours ago

From my blog[0]: "I instinctively type alt + 0151 (Windows) or option + shift + - (Mac). I don’t use it everywhere (e.g., code comments), but I often employ it in my writing—a habit I developed after years of roleplaying in online games with native English speakers.

An "advanced, trusted GPT-4, ChatGPT and AI Detector tool" flagged the text above as 100% "AI GPT". If I swap the em-dash for a hyphen, it drops to 48%.

The em-dash is a stylistic choice that's been around since the 1830s–used to create a break in a sentence.

I don’t know why this particular style of writing is flagged as AI-generated—as if real humans can’t pause for dramatic effect. We're left second-guessing our own voice and swapping out em-dashes for clunky commas—just to prove we're real.

If that makes me sound like a bot—so be it."

[0] https://www.carlos-menezes.com/em-dash-1830-invention/

astahlx

7 hours ago

Using em dash is just fine. Academic writing teached me using it. However, I have to admit that use of AI is accelerating its „adoption“.

nomilk

7 hours ago

tl;dr: The proportion of Reddit comments containing emdashes more than doubled since ChatGPT's release!

From the data: for several years before ChatGPT release, the proportion of Reddit comments containing emdashes was about 0.13-0.17%. For the few years after ChatGPT came out, it's between 0.17% and 0.41%.

jonatron

7 hours ago

Click the % button in the top right

nomilk

7 hours ago

I noticed it shortly after commenting, and completely rewrote my comment accordingly. Excellent research! If you were to do a write-up on how you did this analysis, that would be very interesting (as the number of comments involved is large).

jonatron

6 hours ago

The "dev notes" in the top right links to https://intervolz.com/emdash-observer-writeup/ I downloaded torrents of reddit comments, and processed them in Go, written using AI assistance. Then Intervolz did this thing and wrote it up.

HardwareLust

5 hours ago

Wait, why would people make torrents of reddit comments?