Should I Be Worried About Arsenic in Rice?

15 pointsposted 18 hours ago
by whack

8 Comments

jandrewrogers

16 hours ago

Using the 100 ppb arsenic level as a baseline, and using selenium as a model for daily requirements and toxicity since we don't have one for arsenic, that seems to suggest that up to half a kilo per day of rice should be well-tolerated? Assuming I math-ed it correctly.

There is insufficient data to build an authoritative model of dietary arsenic requirements AFAIK. It is a necessary micronutrient in animal biology and evidence suggests it is similar to selenium in requirement magnitude and toxicity profile, so it is sometimes treated as comparable in the literature. Obviously, it is a rough cut since this was extrapolated from animal models -- we don't have good human models -- but in principle the RDA should be well-tolerated by definition and these levels are endemic in some parts of the world.

ozim

16 hours ago

Feels like going full tin foil hat on fluoride in tooth paste. Most likely it is not really that good for you but having rotten teeth is most likely worse for you than whatever fluoride can do.

Difference would be that most likely arsenic doesn't have as much upsides as the other stuff.

Havoc

15 hours ago

Figure if this was really a problem the Japanese would be front and center. Like you’d at least hear something from the nation that eats 10x as much rice as me

aaroninsf

16 hours ago

TLDR:

“The analysis also showed that brown rice contained more arsenic than white rice.”

“…the levels varied depending on where the rice was grown. The highest concentrations were found in arborio rice from Italy and white and brown rices from the southeastern United States.

Sushi, jasmine and other types of white rice from California, as well as jasmine rice from Thailand and basmati rice from India, had the lowest levels.”

No mention in the article of whether there are differences in conventional and organic products (I would imagine not, if this is a groundwater problem?).

Also of note:

"Though the findings were not published in a peer-reviewed journal, they jibe with past research, said Dojin Ryu, a professor of food toxicology at the University of Missouri. Rice and rice products are typically the most concentrated food sources of inorganic arsenic, according to the F.D.A."