'You've Blown a Hole in the Family': Inside the Murdochs' Succession Drama

14 pointsposted 7 days ago
by JumpCrisscross

18 Comments

gambiting

7 days ago

Very few other people have done as much damage to democracy and broadly defined "social order" as Murdochs, so I'm not going to have any sympathy.

lazyeye

7 days ago

The underlying thesis to a comment like this is that the majority of people are stupid and easily manipulated (not smart like you).

mpalmer

7 days ago

In skipping straight to "oh so Fox News viewers are stupid?", you simultaneously make this about emotion and avoid discussing what the Murdochs actually do.

That could be interesting, but you're choosing to be a weird mix of defensive and aggressive.

lazyeye

7 days ago

Neither you or the comment I was replying to have said anything about "what the Murdochs actually do"?

CamperBob2

7 days ago

That appears to be the null hypothesis at this point. It's up to you to provide evidence to the contrary, ideally in the form of an election that doesn't result in RFK as HHS secretary and Tulsi Gabbard as DNI.

lazyeye

7 days ago

(shrugs) the majority of people voted for this. Why is their opinion of less value than yours?

CamperBob2

7 days ago

Simple self-preservation, if nothing else. Stupid voters constitute a threat to my own well-being, and probably to yours as well.

Again: I'm not the one with questions to answer and propositions to prove.

lazyeye

7 days ago

ok but whatever is going inside your head has no relevance to me or anyone else. And the fact that you feel "threatened" maybe more related to your propensity for being influenced by ideology and the bubble you live in, than anything happening in reality.

moritzwarhier

7 days ago

Why? Do you think that people have to be stupid to be vulnerable to manipulation?

tim333

7 days ago

People do tend to be kind of stupid and easily manipulated regardless of who wrote the comment. I'm often stupid and manipulated myself.

Two4

7 days ago

The best quote I've seen to explain this is from the Men in Black movie: a person is smart, but people are dumb.

Group dynamics and identity politics are massively underestimated by many as motivating forces to get people to act against their interests.

Also remember: half of all people are below average intelligence.

lazyeye

7 days ago

[flagged]

gambiting

7 days ago

Do you think everyone here works in silicon valley? That's an assumption that happens all the time on HN and I personally hate it, there's a lot of us non Americans here.

lazyeye

7 days ago

Yes point taken. I did think that before posting but still thought its true in the general sense. I'm guessing that on average the people on HN are being paid alot more than the general population regardless of location.

cyanydeez

7 days ago

No, the underlying thesis is bullshit artists are selffullfilling prophecies.

viraptor

7 days ago

The most interesting part for me was Rupert's quote

> Fox and our papers are the only faintly conservative voices against the monolithic liberal media.

I would love to know if he actually believes that or does he say that even in private just in case. Not that it matters for the results, but there's a few characters in really high positions these days where I can't tell if they're actively lying or just lost in their world.

CamperBob2

7 days ago

Well, the Murdochs blew a hole in democracy, so it seems only fair.