CuriouslyC
12 hours ago
We are, but we have incentives against it. Your career as a self-educated generalist is going to be significantly worse than as a credentialed specialist. You're going to get weeded out by HR drones for good positions and the positions that you do get an interview for, they're going to try and put you in a box like a specialist and make you a cog in a machine, so you won't get to even use your full skillset.
butterfly42069
12 hours ago
Yup, as someone in this position HR want nothing to do with me.
My only options have been to make companies or freelance.
I do think the world needs more "generalists" though as we're often the only ones placed to even half understand, combine and fully utilise different specialists.
jltsiren
12 hours ago
A "Renaissance person" is not a self-educated generalist but an old person who has had diverse interests and the motivation and the opportunities to pursue them.
If you work on something full time for five years, deliberately challenging yourself and striving to improve your skills, you will probably become pretty good at the thing. But because a full-time job is only 1/3 of your waking hours, you'll have time for other pursuits. If there are 50 productive years in a human live, you can probably become pretty good at 20 different things.
From this perspective, a college degree is not specialization, but the first few percent of the work of becoming a Renaissance person.
from-nibly
11 hours ago
> A "Renaissance person" is not a self-educated generalist
> an old person who has had diverse interests and the motivation and the opportunities to pursue them.
How is that not the same thing? The only difference is that you added that they had to be old.
jltsiren
11 hours ago
First, because the "self-educated" part is irrelevant here.
But more importantly, the difference is in the degree. Generalism is a matter of interests and focus. A Renaissance person is an ideal and an outcome. The Renaissance ideal was that elite men should strive to be good at everything they do. In the recent history, the people who have been called Renaissance men were typically at the top of their fields, with significant accomplishments in other fields. And those accomplishments take time.