A stalled Waymo brought Kamala Harris' motorcade to a halt in SF

57 pointsposted 11 hours ago
by rntn

57 Comments

crazygringo

10 hours ago

It doesn't even say for how long. 5 minutes? 10 minutes? Especially since apparently a police officer was able to hop right in and drive it out of the way.

I'm more curious why stalled Waymo's aren't being immediately detected by Waymo, and remote drivers/controllers aren't immediately manually addressing the situation.

Or are they, and this would have been resolved in the next 5 minutes anyways?

dghlsakjg

9 hours ago

If you look at the footage it looks a lot like nothing material actually happened.

There was a stuck Waymo at Mason and California near the Fairmont Hotel's main entrance on Mason. The VP was also stopping at the hotel's main entrance. From the footage it isn't even clear that the motorcade stopped, or was delayed by the Waymo since it was more or less at its destination.

dawnerd

10 hours ago

Exactly, sounds like a publication trying to target two popular subjects

babl-yc

10 hours ago

If this is the the most concerning Waymo headline for the month @ 100k rides/week I'd say things are going pretty well on their end

ceejayoz

10 hours ago

I think this is more concerning for the Secret Service than Waymo.

AlotOfReading

10 hours ago

I would be shocked if Waymo doesn't start avoiding motorcade routes preemptively just to prevent this headline from ever occurring again. They're extremely sensitive to bad PR given the nature of the industry.

buildbot

10 hours ago

I think part of the issue is those routes are somewhat unknown ahead of time?

AlotOfReading

10 hours ago

The SS can and does make that information available when necessary, for instance to private toll bridge operators. Waymo doesn't need significant advance notice either, just minutes for normal vehicles.

goldcd

10 hours ago

I suspect the easiest thing would be a "return to base and shutdown" button that the Secret Service could trigger at short notice - would cause problems for everything wanting to use a Waymo, but I suspect the SS are quite OK with causing disruption already.

klyrs

9 hours ago

Sounds like fake movie spy shit to me. It turns out, the Secret Service is an organization of humans with ordinary lives and a relatively modest budget.

uoaei

10 hours ago

I imagine the Secret Service is considering some kind of routing override for those vehicles.

nativeit

9 hours ago

It’s called the “tow truck protocol”. The specifics are too complicated to get into here, but it involves a phone call, and sometimes they bring in an outside agency known only as “AAA”.

newfocogi

10 hours ago

It appears that a police officer was able to enter the Waymo to move it. I’ve never heard of this before. Are law enforcement trained to do this in all areas that Waymo operates? Can a random person open the door of a Waymo and move it at will?

kotaKat

10 hours ago

https://waymo.com/firstresponders/

Waymo has an emergency team that will guide LE on taking over a Waymo. They'll shut it down, pop the doors, and give them a code to punch in on the wheel controls to disengage it and put it in manual mode to shuttle it out of the way.

Brian_K_White

10 hours ago

This kinda sounds like employing the police to do your job.

Police/Fire etc should absolutely have this ability, but that is a seperate issue.

jorvi

10 hours ago

If your ordinary car breaks down in the middle of a busy road, then yeah the police or fire department will indeed help you push it out of the way (if bystanders aren’t already). You wouldn’t say that’s the responsibility of Toyota.

Brian_K_White

5 hours ago

It's not about the car or the manufactirer, it's about the operator.

The closest analogy would be when the driver of an ordinary car becomes incapacitated.

In that case, the police or someone acting on the polices behalf can and will move the vehicle and then the owner pays for that later. But there IS an operator who is responsible for the vehicle unless some misfortune happens.

A self driving car sseems more like letting other people deal with any problems you caused by letting that car loose on the road.

Basically the same as parking a regular car somewhere it's not supposed to be and leaving it.

"Oh if this car I left in front of the firehouse is in the way, just call this number and I'll tell you some instructions how to unlock the car and drive it somewhere else for me."

nickthegreek

10 hours ago

The police should be able to levy some sort of fine/fee for this imo.

SteveNuts

10 hours ago

I understand this is a slippery slope argument on my part, but why is this any different from the emergency services pushing a non-autonomous vehicle out of the way to clear traffic?

What if it’s a privately owned bus, or a taxi? Would those companies foot the bill for their disabled vehicle?

ninth_ant

10 hours ago

If a private company leaves operational vehicles in the middle of streets and requires city services to move them to unblock public roads... sure, let's charge them. Is that something that is happening? Is that more likely to start happening we make this change? This slope is beyond slippery.

bonzini

10 hours ago

Well, they should? Or if they prefer, their insurance will pay on their behalf.

SpicyLemonZest

10 hours ago

It depends on whether you see it as a piece of machinery that's broken, or a non-human driver that's choosing to violate the rules of the road. As the article mentions, it sounds like California has chosen the second and plans to begin issuing citations.

Aerroon

10 hours ago

If police/fire get this ability commonly then will they start asking for it with regular cars as well?

weaksauce

10 hours ago

they already do this regularly. just instead of driving it off the road they ram it with their vehicles off the road. edit: or if there's time they will tow it.

nativeit

10 hours ago

Traditionally, this is called “towing”.

paulddraper

10 hours ago

If the driver is incapacitated, they will move the vehicle themselves

valval

10 hours ago

Moving a car if the driver is incapacitated or not present?

dyauspitr

10 hours ago

Police clear debris off the road after an accident. By that logic they’re taking sanitation worker jobs.

whimsicalism

10 hours ago

view it as a subsidy of the technology, which i think we should be doing

bink

10 hours ago

I've seen a Waymo block the Muni tracks before. When a train finally showed up a cop appeared in less than a minute. They didn't jump in the car but they did knock on the window and speak to a support rep. The rep was able to instruct the car to move forward and turn onto a side street. It then blocked the side street for a bit before eventually moving on.

While I'm not against self-driving taxis I have some serious concerns over how these cars will impact emergency response in an earthquake or fire if the cars become more prevalent.

paulddraper

10 hours ago

> I have some serious concerns over how these cars will impact emergency response in an earthquake or fire

More than meatbags?

bink

6 hours ago

If a meatbag comes upon a downed power pole, broken fire hydrant, fender bender, or sunken stretch of pavement they're usually pretty good about turning around or avoiding the obstacle. I haven't seen the same from these taxis yet.

pclmulqdq

10 hours ago

The meatbags are panicky apes, but they know how to get out of they way.

dghlsakjg

10 hours ago

Have you ever really watched an emergency vehicle try to get through a traffic clogged road.

The Meatbags most certainly do not now how to get out of the way.

pclmulqdq

9 hours ago

Do you, by chance, live in NYC? That is the only place I have lived where the meatbags regularly do not get out of the way of sirens. In most other places, they make a great effort.

dghlsakjg

9 hours ago

Nope.

This is true for everywhere I have lived in North America. Outside of NYC it isn't so much people not caring, as people not realizing that the siren is mostly to tell you to clear the way. A lot of people just take it to mean "stop where you are", when the actual intention is "move out of the way, then stop". I travel along a route near a hospital frequently, and it is incredibly common for people to be stopped in front of an ambulance, blocking the path, while the ambulance blasts their horn trying to get them to move out of the way.

thrill

10 hours ago

I've personally seen more than once the meatbags confuse the accelerator for the brake.

whimsicalism

10 hours ago

> Can a random person open the door of a Waymo and move it at will?

No, IIRC they all have law enforcement procedures which probably include ability to move car

plorg

10 hours ago

Need this defcon talk.

nativeit

9 hours ago

Presumably delivered in a keynote from Tony the tow truck driver.

dist-epoch

10 hours ago

You can hear the police officer speaking with someone through the car open window.

AlotOfReading

10 hours ago

"Autonomous car blocks motorcade" is one chase scene away from a scifi thriller. It truly is the future.

charlie0

10 hours ago

The thought this was done on purpose to send a message crossed my mind. The Dems have been rather anti-tech lately. Would make for a good sci-fi movie.

dcmatt

10 hours ago

This feels like I, Robot— except instead of killer robots in a tunnel, we’ve got driverless cars cluelessly blocking motorcades

hi-v-rocknroll

9 hours ago

This would be de rigueur for what Cruise did in Austin, except to everyone else who wasn't a POTUS candidate.

dyauspitr

10 hours ago

Honestly, Waymo seems to be killing it. If this is what the growing pains look like it’s totally acceptable imo.

paulddraper

10 hours ago

FYI for anyone that doesn't drive, this happens with human drivers too.

I helped push a drivered car out of an intersection Thursday.