Elon Musk's Midlife Crisis over Populating Mars

11 pointsposted 12 hours ago
by bookofjoe

8 Comments

foundart

11 hours ago

I wonder what it would be like to live in a Martian settlement controlled by Musk.

beardyw

10 hours ago

Actually and perhaps surprisingly I think it would be only marginally worse than just living in a Martian settlement. First go and live in a submarine and if you like it, apply to go.

gregjor

10 hours ago

Solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short.

gregjor

10 hours ago

At best Musk suffers from adolescent delusions. At worst the Mars plan amounts to a stock pump and a way to stay in the headlines. The main takeaway from the media coverage of the imaginary Mars colony: the press seems too gullible and too ignorant to ask questions.

If we could send millions of kilograms into orbit and then to Mars we could deflect an incoming asteroid.

If we could “terraform” Mars — a planet with no magnetosphere and therefore incapable of holding on to an atmosphere — we could fix the damage done to Earth.

If we could keep people alive for the journey and then long-term on Mars, fit enough to reproduce, we could fix a lot of medical/health problems here.

We don’t have human colonies in the ocean, a much less hostile environment than Mars. We don’t have colonies on the moon either. We struggle to maintain the planet we evolved on in a livable state.

Starship so far has not achieved low-earth orbit, carrying any cargo, much less humans, refueling in orbit, etc. We do have some new debris fields making this planet a little less habitable.

If we want to talk seriously about saving our species we might start with identifying sociopaths and not mistaking their lies and self-serving schemes for anything to do with the common good.

Zigurd

7 hours ago

Both Tesla and SpaceX have wild valuations that mostly depend on future promises: SpaceX's Starlink will be a species-wide communications provider - all the way to Mars. Teslas will drive themselves and replace all other forms of ground transportation. If you stop believing, Tinkerbell, which is to say the meme, dies.

Reality is that even though 5G FWA is only recently rolled out it has several times as many subscribers as Starlink. FWA costs about half in the US and very likely even cheaper in the developing world where mobile service is cheaper than in the US. The TAM for satellite internet will be limited to cases where 5G FWA can't reach.

user

11 hours ago

[deleted]