rsp1984
5 hours ago
Without taking away anything from the substance or achievement of this release, I find phrases like "openpilot is an operating system for robotics." always quite fishy.
No, it's not an OS for robotics. You can't do actual robotics stuff with it, like drive actuators to control limbs or grippers, do motion control or SLAM or perception or any of the usual robotics stack.
Their website correctly says openpilot is an open source advanced driver assistance system that works on 275+ car models of Toyota, Hyundai, Honda, and many other brands. Should've stuck to that.
Thinking about it some more, it's probably just another engagement baiting strategy to get attention and I'm their gullible puppet. Well played.
conradev
2 hours ago
I believe the idea is that openpilot replaces the usual robotics stack with an end to end neural net.
While I agree operating system is usually a marketing term, it does feel correct in this case as it is the operating system for the Comma Three, which can operate cars but also this thing: https://www.comma.ai/shop/body
metal_am
4 hours ago
I definitely thought it was a ROS clone based on that first line.
punnerud
3 hours ago
Isn’t the software for training end-to-end NN to be used in automation? Just a first version that it’s used for cars, and they have been using it for their own robot.
So the claim still stands?
tamimio
2 hours ago
Yeah came to say the same, I thought a new big player is in the market. It looks great nonetheless.